The Ball Blog
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Trade Grades
    • Season Predictions: 2016
    • Power Rankings: 2015-16
    • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios
    • NBA PG's Chat >
      • Establishing Personalities, Part 2
      • Establishing Personalities, Part 1
      • Free Agency
      • Rookies
      • Season in Review
      • Champs!
      • Ganging Up
      • I'm Rooting For...
      • Finals!
      • Choked!
      • Buzzer-Beater!
      • MVP!
    • Best Case Scenarios for Playoff Teams
    • Draft Targets
    • Season Predictions: 2014-15
    • One Trade That Every Team Should Do
    • State of the Franchise
  • Teams
    • Atlantic >
      • Boston Celtics >
        • Trade Grades Celtics
        • Season Predictions 2016 Celtics
        • Power Rankings Celtics
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Celtics
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Celtics
        • Draft Targets Celtics
        • Season Predictions Celtics
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Celtics
        • State of the Franchise Celtics
      • Brooklyn Nets >
        • Trade Grades Nets
        • Season Predictions 2016 Nets
        • Power Rankings Nets
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Nets
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Nets
        • Draft Targets Nets
        • Season Predictions Nets
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Nets
        • State of the Franchise Nets
      • New York Knicks >
        • Trade Grades Knicks
        • Season Predictions 2016 Knicks
        • Power Rankings Knicks
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Knicks
        • Draft Targets Knicks
        • Season Predictions Knicks
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Knicks
        • State of the Franchise Knicks
      • Philadelphia 76ers >
        • Trade Graders 76ers
        • Season Predictions 2016 76ers
        • Power Rankings 76ers
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios 76ers
        • Draft Targets 76ers
        • Season Predictions 76ers
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do 76ers
        • State of the Franchise 76ers
      • Toronto Raptors >
        • Trade Grades Raptors
        • Season Predictions 2016 Raptors
        • Power Rankings Raptors
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Raptors
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Raptors
        • Draft Targets Raptors
        • Season Predictions Raptors
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Raptors
        • State of the Franchise Raptors
    • Central >
      • Chicago Bulls >
        • Trade Grades Bulls
        • Season Predictions 2016 Bulls
        • Power Rankings Bulls
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Bulls
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Bulls
        • Draft Targets Bulls
        • Season Predictions Bulls
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Bulls
        • State of the Franchise Bulls
        • OLD Chicago Bulls
      • Cleveland Cavaliers >
        • Trade Grades Cavaliers
        • Season Predictions 2016 Cavaliers
        • Power Rankings Cavaliers
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Cavaliers
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Cavaliers
        • Draft Targets Cavaliers
        • Season Predictions Cavaliers
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Cavaliers
        • State of the Franchise Cavaliers
      • Detroit Pistons >
        • Trade Grades Pistons
        • Season Predictions 2016 Pistons
        • Power Rankings Pistons
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Pistons
        • Draft Targets Pistons
        • Season Predictions Pistons
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Pistons
        • State of the Franchise Pistons
      • Indiana Pacers >
        • Trade Grades Pacers
        • Season Predictions 2016 Pacers
        • Power Rankings Pacers
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Pacers
        • Draft Targets Pacers
        • Season Predictions Pacers
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Pacers
        • State of the Franchise Pacers
        • OLD Indiana Pacers
      • Milwaukee Bucks >
        • Trade Grades Bucks
        • Season Predictions 2016 Bucks
        • Power Rankings Bucks
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Bucks
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Bucks
        • Draft Targets Bucks
        • Season Predictions Bucks
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Bucks
        • State of the Franchise Bucks
        • OLD Milwaukee Bucks
    • Southeast >
      • Atlanta Hawks >
        • Trade Grades Hawks
        • Season Predictions 2016 Hawks
        • Power Rankings Hawks
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Hawks
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Hawks
        • Draft Targets Hawks
        • Season Predictions Hawks
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Hawks
        • State of the Franchise Hawks
      • Charlotte Hornets >
        • Trade Grades Hornets
        • Season Predictions 2016 Hornets
        • Power Rankings Hornets
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Hornets
        • Draft Targets Hornets
        • Season Predictions Hornets
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Hornets
        • State of the Franchise Hornets
      • Miami Heat >
        • Trade Grades Heat
        • Season Predictions 2016 Heat
        • Power Rankings Heat
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Heat
        • Draft Targets Heat
        • Season Predictions Heat
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Heat
        • State of the Franchise Heat
      • Orlando Magic >
        • Trade Grades Magic
        • Season Predictions 2016 Magic
        • Power Rankings Magic
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Magic
        • Draft Targets Magic
        • Season Predictions Magic
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Magic
        • State of the Franchise Magic
      • Washington Wizards >
        • Trade Grades Wizards
        • Season Predictions 2016 Wizards
        • Power Rankings Wizards
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Wizards
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Wizards
        • Draft Targets Wizards
        • Season Predictions Wizards
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Wizards
        • State of the Franchise Wizards
    • Northwest >
      • Denver Nuggets >
        • Trade Grades Nuggets
        • Season Predictions 2016 Nuggets
        • Power Rankings Nuggets
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Nuggets
        • Draft Targets Nuggets
        • Season Predictions Nuggets
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Nuggets
        • State of the Franchise Nuggets
      • Minnesota Timberwolves >
        • Trade Grades Timberwolves
        • Season Predictions 2016 Timberwolves
        • Power Rankings Timberwolves
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Timberwolves
        • Draft Targets Timberwolves
        • Season Predictions Timberwolves
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Timberwolves
        • State of the Franchise Timberwolves
      • Oklahoma City Thunder >
        • Trade Grades Thunder
        • Season Predictions 2016 Thunder
        • Power Rankings Thunder
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Thunder
        • Draft Targets Thunder
        • Season Predictions Thunder
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Thunder
        • State of the Franchise Thunder
      • Portland Trail Blazers >
        • Trade Grades Blazers
        • Season Predictions 2016 Blazers
        • Power Rankings Blazers
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Blazers
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Blazers
        • Draft Targets Blazers
        • Season Predictions Blazers
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Blazers
        • State of the Franchise Blazers
      • Utah Jazz >
        • Trade Grades Jazz
        • Season Predictions 2016 Jazz
        • Power Rankings Jazz
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Jazz
        • Draft Targets Jazz
        • Season Predictions Jazz
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Jazz
        • State of the Franchise Jazz
    • Pacific >
      • Golden State Warriors >
        • Trade Grades Warriors
        • Season Predictions 2016 Warriors
        • Power Rankings Warriors
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Warriors
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Warriors
        • Draft Targets Warriors
        • Season Predictions Warriors
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Warriors
        • State of the Franchise Warriors
      • Los Angeles Clippers >
        • Trade Grades Clippers
        • Season Predictions 2016 Clippers
        • Power Rankings Clippers
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Clippers
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Clippers
        • Draft Targets Clippers
        • Season Predictions Clippers
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Clippers
        • State of the Franchise Clippers
      • Los Angeles Lakers >
        • Trade Grades Lakers
        • Season Predictions 2016 Lakers
        • Power Rankings Lakers
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Lakers
        • Draft Targets Lakers
        • Season Predictions Lakers
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Lakers
        • State of the Franchise Lakers
      • Phoenix Suns >
        • Trade Grades Suns
        • Season Predictions 2016 Suns
        • Power Rankings Suns
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Suns
        • Draft Targets Suns
        • Season Predictions Suns
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Suns
        • State of the Franchise Suns
      • Sacramento Kings >
        • Trade Grades Kings
        • Season Predictions 2016 Kings
        • Power Rankings Kings
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Kings
        • Draft Targets Kings
        • Season Predictions Kings
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Kings
        • State of the Franchise Kings
    • Southwest >
      • Dallas Mavericks >
        • Trade Grades Mavericks
        • Season Predictions 2016 Mavericks
        • Power Rankings Mavericks
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Mavericks
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Mavericks
        • Draft Targets Mavericks
        • Season Predictions Mavericks
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Mavericks
        • State of the Franchise Mavericks
      • Houston Rockets >
        • Trade Grades Rockets
        • Season Predictions 2016 Rockets
        • Power Rankings Rockets
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Rockets
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Rockets
        • Draft Targets Rockets
        • Season Predictions Rockets
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Rockets
        • State of the Franchise Rockets
      • Memphis Grizzlies >
        • Trade Grades Grizzlies
        • Season Predictions 2016 Grizzlies
        • Power Rankings Grizzlies
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Grizzlies
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Grizzlies
        • Draft Targets Grizzlies
        • Season Predictions Grizzlies
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Grizzlies
        • State of the Franchise Grizzlies
      • New Orleans Pelicans >
        • Trade Grades Pelicans
        • Season Predictions 2016 Pelicans
        • Power Rankings Pelicans
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Pelicans
        • Best Case Scenario For Every Playoff Team Pelicans
        • Draft Targets Pelicans
        • Season Predictions Pelicans
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Pelicans
        • State of the Franchise Pelicans
      • San Antonio Spurs >
        • Trade Grades Spurs
        • Season Predictions 2016 Spurs
        • Power Rankings Spurs
        • Best, Worst Draft Scenarios Spurs
        • Best Case Scenario for Playoff Teams Spurs
        • Draft Targets Spurs
        • Season Predictions Spurs
        • One Trade That Every Team Should Do Spurs
        • State of the Franchise Spurs
  • Weekly Survey
  • Trivia
    • 1960s and Earlier >
      • 1960s-Easy
      • 1960s-Medium
      • 1960s-Hard
    • 1970s >
      • 1970s-Easy
      • 1970s-Medium
      • 1970s-Hard
    • 1980s >
      • 1980s-Easy
      • 1980s-Medium
      • 1980s-Hard
    • 1990s >
      • 1990s-Easy
      • 1990s-Medium
      • 1990s-Hard
    • 2000s >
      • 2000s-Easy
      • 2000s-Medium
      • 2000s-Hard
    • 2010s/Present >
      • 2010s-Easy
      • 2010s-Medium
      • 2010s-Hard
    • General >
      • General-Easy
      • General-Medium
      • General-Hard
    • All-time Records >
      • Records-Easier
      • Records-Harder
  • Blog
    • Evaluating NBA Teams' Drafting >
      • Outline
      • Coefficients
      • Grooming the Data Set
      • Final Rankings
    • Sizing up the 2016-17 MVP Race >
      • The Warriors
      • Familiar Faces
      • Team's Just Not Good Enough
      • The Dark Horses
      • The Man Nobody Sees Coming
    • Playoff Predictions >
      • Playoff Predictions: East
      • Playoff Predictions: West
    • This Week in Basketball...
    • Unpopular Opinions: Draft Day 2017
    • Free Agency News: 2017
  • Us
    • About Us
    • Contact Us

The Ball Blog's Blog

How to fix the broken all-star voting system

1/23/2016

2 Comments

 
​Draymond Green. James Harden. DeMarcus Cousins. Anthony Davis. Blake Griffin. Chris Paul.
But alas, it was Kobe, yet again.
 
The Black Mamba rounded out the West’s All-Star starting five, announced on Wednesday. Joining Bryant are Stephen Curry, Russell Westbrook, Kawhi Leonard, and Kevin Durant.
 
Look, Kobe is an all-time great for sure. Top 10, maybe even top 5 -- ever. Period. But that was then, and this is now.
 
“Then” saw Kobe win five rings, in 2000, ‘01, ‘02, ‘09, and 2010; “then” saw Kobe finally win his first MVP in 2008; “then” saw the Mamba drop 81 points on the Raptors in 2006.
 
But “now” sees Kobe as a 37 year old man; “now” sees a worn-out body who is coming off of three straight season-ending injuries; “now” is Bryant shooting 34.5% from the field.
 
The “now” Kobe is hardly even reminiscent of the “then” Kobe. That is both a compliment and an insult:
 
It is a compliment in that it emphasizes that Kobe was so much better than this, and this final season of his will not be what we remember his legacy by.
It is an insult in that Kobe is bad this season. Really bad, especially for his own gargantuan standards.
 
More importantly, it is an insult to the fans who keep voting for him. Which brings me back to my original point.
 
The league Player Efficiency Rating (PER) average is 15.0. Anthony Davis’ is 24.96, Chris Paul’s is 24.86, Harden’s is 24.35, Cousins’ is 23.89.
These players make up the 6 through 9th ranked spots in the PER list so far this season. Curry is of course on top with 32.67, and Blake Griffin checks in at number 14 with 23.55.
 
Now, where is Kobe, you ask? So did I, and I actually had a difficult time finding him. But there he was, finally, on Page 5 of the rankings, coming in at 202nd, with a whopping PER of 12.84:

Picture
​You thought I was joking.
 
The point is, and it should be quite obvious by now, is that Kobe does not deserve to be an All-Star starter. Much less does he deserve to be called a top 10 player anymore, or a top 50, or a top 100, or a top first four pages. In absolutely no way, shape, or form, does he even come close to being close to the aforementioned West superstars. He is depriving a spot from those who truly deserve it.
 
But Kobe didn’t vote himself into the All-Star game. So who’s really to blame?
 
Well, the short and obvious answer is the fans. They voted Kobe into the All-Star game. In fact, 1.9 million of them did, making Kobe the top vote-getter -- higher than Curry (1.6 million) and approximately the same as LeBron and Durant combined (total of 2.0 million). The fans also made fan-favorite Maverick center Zaza Pachulia the 6th highest vote-getter in the West. Pachulia finished with 768,000 votes, and Westbrook barely edged him out with 772,000.
 
It’s crazy. It really is. Curry and Westbrook are the two best players in the NBA this season according to our trustworthy PER statistic (at 32.67 and 29.04, respectively), while Pachulia is 69th with 17.83 and Kobe is, of course, 202nd with 12.84. So how can we possibly justify the voting results?
 
We can’t. There is no justification, only an explanation. And it’s a sad, troubling explanation too -- one that I didn’t want to have to come to, but it’s the only one that makes sense:
 
The All-Star voting has become a popularity, not a talent, contest.
 
It’s true -- you may recall that in 2013-14, Kobe was voted in as an All-Star starter. Just one problem: Bryant had played all of 6 games that season, was injured during the entire voting process and could not play in the All-Star game anyways. The sad truth is that Bryant became an All-Star the past three seasons not because he was talented, but because he used to be talented, because he’s famous, because he’s Kobe Freakin’ Bryant and the fans will just vote for their favorite players, whether those players deserve it or not.
 
But again, Kobe didn’t vote himself into the All-Star game. So who’s really to blame?
 
Well, the longer and more complicated answer is the NBA. They are the ones who allow us fans to vote in the first place. How it works is that the fans vote for the 10 All-Star starters, while the NBA coaches select the remaining 20 All-Stars.
 
Oddly enough, I’ve rarely heard people complain about the coaches’ decisions. But every year, the fans select the wrong players, and every year, fans are upset with their own decisions.
 
Why can’t we just have the coaches choose the whole roster?
 
Well the counter-argument is that All-Star weekend is just an entertainment event, so the fans should be able to choose who they want to watch. But it’s so much more than that.
 
How many All-Star selections a player has is of outsized importance. There are bonuses put into contracts depending on if a player gets selected, and it’s used as one of the main measuring sticks when assessing a player’s stardom level, thus affecting how much money they get in the first place.
 
And it’s also used as a measuring stick for greatness:

Picture
While perhaps a less perfect list than say, ranking by MVP awards, the all-time All Star list is actually a fairly comprehensive ranking of legends, albeit with flaws. Now do you see why Kobe’s last three All-Star appearances-- none of which he deserved -- matter so much?
 
Kobe will be retiring at season’s end, and of course the buzz over where he ranks all-time is only starting up. Kobe should have 15 All-Stars, making him tied with the likes of Duncan, Garnett, and O’Neal for 2nd all-time. But Bryant has 18 All-Stars in 20 seasons, giving off the false notion of dominance even in the twilight of his legendary career. Maybe with 18 All-Stars people will rank him sixth instead of seventh, ahead of Larry Bird instead of just behind him, as the greatest Laker ever, instead of behind Magic Johnson. Even if it makes no difference in the aforementioned comparisons, the fact of the matter is that Bryant doesn’t deserve to be right there on this list with Kareem , who dominated the game every single season for two entire decades, sans the 1978 season when Kareem was injured.
 
On the flip side, what happens if a Karl Anthony-Towns or a Damian Lillard (21st and 26th in PER, respectively) misses out on the All-Star game because Kobe took their spot? It’s actually not even “what if”, it’s a “when”, because naturally there is now one less spot for a deserving player in the West. It changes everything, and it's extremely unfortunate for the younger stars, as it has been for the past few years.
 
Perhaps there is a solution, however --  one that allows both the fans to get their entertainment value, and for the true All-Stars to be All-Stars:
 
The fans select the entire rosters. All 30 guys. And they get to see all of their fan favorites play. But the NBA makes a “Coach’s All-Stars, allowing the coaches to make  a separate list of two 15-man rosters. Overlap between the “Fans’ All-Stars” and the “Coaches’ All-Stars” is bound to occur and is absolutely fine.
 
Here, we can use the “Coach’s All-Stars” list when measuring how good a player actually is, and the fans can vote for as many Zaza Pachulia’s as they want, because none of it will actually matter.
 
Likely the biggest objection to this would be that some of the true stars, who will be selected by the coaches, won’t get the “honor” of participating in the game, but we all know that it’s just a game. Nobody even tries in it anyways -- there is never any defense played, and the whole thing is one giant dunk contest. Excellent entertainment value for sure, and that’s what the NBA is going for.
 
So if what the NBA wants is to appease the fans (in order to acquire maximum $$), then let them choose the entire rosters. Just don’t allow any of it to actually matter: leave the important decisions up to only the most intelligent voters: the coaches. Everybody wins.
 
Look, I get that you (1.9 million of you) want to see Kobe in his last All-Star game, for one reason or another. Sentimental factors and stuff like that. That’s fine -- I’d like for The Mamba to receive a proper goodbye as well. But the next time you vote, just think about what you’re doing first, think of the impact it will have on those who deserve it, and think: “Am I only voting for this person because they’re famous?”
 
That applies to basketball, as well as politics.
2 Comments
James Carlson link
11/5/2022 09:33:47 pm

Fly free investment or six perhaps avoid. Concern out sport next surface. Really crime month sea national message.

Reply
Basement Underpinning New Jersey link
1/28/2023 01:03:02 am

Interresting thoughts

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Archives

    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    January 2016

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
© 2015 The Ball Blog